Martha's Osteria
About Martha's Osteria
Martha's Osteria is an Italian restaurant located at 338 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY, with a price range of $20–30. It is known for its homemade pastas crafted from fresh, high-quality ingredients and a menu that balances classic Italian dishes with approachable options like burgers and salads. The restaurant accommodates various dietary needs and provides a kid-friendly environment.
Customers frequently highlight the friendly staff, warm atmosphere, and thoughtful execution of dishes. The restaurant is suited for both casual family meals and special nights out, with a strong bar and wine selection complementing the food. Reviews commend Martha’s Osteria for delivering high flavor and consistency without pretension, making it a favored neighborhood spot for repeat visits.
-
Pricing sits in that sweet spot that says “quality worth paying for” without veering into the pretentious. For the quality and care you get, Martha’s Osteria feels like a place you could return to again and again — for date night, a dinner with friends, or a spontaneous evening when good food is the goal. Overall: A strong 4.7⭐ experience with classic Italian soul, thoughtful execution, and that Brooklyn warmth that just feels right.
-
LOVE MARTHA'S and my girl Lilo will put u on The grilled octopus was so good we ate half of it before getting a proper picture. Highly Recommend!
-
Been here a couple of times and the food continues to blow me away!!! High quality, so much flavor and willing to make accommodations. Truly a phenomenal experience every time! Ps: Get the Bread Pudding for dessert!
-
• Pappardelle that melts into your soul. • Here, pasta is lived, not just eaten. • Italian tradition in every strand of pasta. • Made fresh, crafted to make you fall in love. • Artisan pasta, five-star level.
-
Best Caesar salad in the area. Great brunch options, and even better dinner options. You can easily go deep Italian or just have a burger and fries and you will be happy either way. Very kid friendly, very accommodating for allergies and other needs. Strong bar and wine selection.
-
My friend I had such a lovely experience here. The waitress was kind and hospitable. The atmosphere was great and everything we ordered was super flavorful. We will definitely be coming back with friends. I also would highly recommend this place as a date spot!
-
Went here with friends and wow it was sooo amazing!! Went a second time for last minute dinner plans and wow its was fantastic both times!! Great Italian food, with pretty presentation, & the atmosphere is warm and friendly. Def keeping this spot in my rotation
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What are some popular dishes at Martha's Osteria?
Try their homemade pastas like pappardelle and the grilled octopus, plus their famous bread pudding for dessert.
-
Can I walk in, or do I need a reservation?
Walk-ins are welcome, but reservations are a good idea for busy times or special occasions.
-
Does Martha's Osteria offer dine-in and takeaway options?
Yes, you can enjoy meals both dining in or taking away, with fast service either way.
-
What is the atmosphere like at Martha's Osteria?
It’s a cozy, casual spot with friendly staff, perfect for family meals, date nights, or casual hangouts.
-
Does the restaurant accommodate groups and accept card payments?
Yes, Martha's Osteria is great for groups and accepts credit and debit cards for payment.
Nearby Italian restaurants
Are you the owner?
Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.
Claim this page
The most charming neighborhood Italian restaurant (formerly Mexican-food eatery)! Truly such wonderful vibes all around. The staff is so friendly and I've really enjoyed connecting with them. The food is DIVINE and an incredible bang-for-your-buck for this neighborhood and quality level!! Homemade pastas and the FRESHIEST ingredients (and tableside bread, duh). Perfect place for a special night out and/or casual family meal.. this place does it all! I almost want to keep news of this place to myself but... I'm being a good samaritan. You're welcome :)